> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://hydroxide.me/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# A Reflection on the Ethics of AI-Generated Code in Video Games
- URL: https://hydroxide.me/ai-in-games-ed/
- Published: 2026-11-18T20:46:43.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-18T20:46:43.000Z
- Description: Just five years ago, you would have been able to buy & download any game off of the Steam store knowing full well it was made by humans, quality or not.
- Author: Darryl McNeil
- Tags: Editorials

Just five years ago, you would have been able to buy & download any game off of the Steam store knowing full well it was made by humans, quality or not. Fast-forward to today, AI-generated "slop" games crowd out the marketplace, often hindering the launch of new titles due to AI-generated clones being made so rapidly. As a result, the entire industry has been awash with what can only be described as "panic" about the ethics of AI disclosures and generative AI usage in video games. 

At the forefront of this discussion is the recent public outcry over indie studio House House, the developers of [*Big Walk*](https://hydroxide.me/big-walk-review/), disclosing (albeit several months after release) that they had used generative AI in order to fix bugs in the code of their game. While the general sentiment in gaming communities has been that AI-generated artwork, music, voice acting, and other artistic elements are effectively a scarlet letter, there has yet to be a consensus about the ethics of AI-generated or AI-assisted code. As someone who is impacted by this discussion, both as a consumer of games, and as a critical reviewer of games, I feel it's necessary to actually look at what nuance there is to both sides of the argument, because despite what the "pundits" on Twitter might have you believe, this is not a black and white issue. 

On one hand, you have folks who believe that code is just as much of an artform as visual art and music. The argument to be made here is that learning to code effectively is a large time sink the same way that becoming a master at creating art or producing music is, and thus the outputs should be regarded with the same level of discretion when it comes to generating them with AI. 

On the other hand, you have people who view AI as a tool to be used in tandem with existing skills. This crowd believes that using an LLM to generate a solution to a given coding problem is inherently the same as posting a question on Stack Overflow and copy & pasting the code another member of the community created.

While there are definitely more extremist opinions, like those who believe that all AI use is ethical, the majority of people fall in a spectrum between these two opinions, varying in the degree in which they believe AI is un/ethical in addition to where and when it should be disclosed, if at all. 

As someone who is not a subject matter expert in journalism, or AI/information systems, I reached out to one of my professors at the University of Georgia, [Dr. Amrit Tiwana](https://sites.google.com/site/atiwana/?ref=hydroxide.me), for comment on a few questions that pertain to the issue from a high level standpoint. 

**Q: At what point does the use of generative AI become unethical (in the scope of the arts)?** 

> "I don’t think AI is **inherently** unethical, any more than a synthesizer was when it first showed up and unsettled the people who worked with older tools. The trouble starts with how someone uses the technology rather than with the technology itself. The ethical problems surface when AI use involves misappropriating other people’s work, misrepresenting who actually made something, or deceiving an audience. "

> The distinction I find helpful is between AI as a tool that extends human creativity, much as a Stanley power drill extends a carpenter’s abilities, \[or\] AI as a substitute for that creativity ... the substitution becomes troubling when it’s quietly passed off as your own work.

**Q: Do you consider writing code to be on the same level as generating art or music with genAI?** 

> "Code is a means to an end, so we ultimately judge it by what it does once it runs, much as we judge a bridge by whether it carries traffic rather than by who poured the concrete. Art/music/books in contrast are themselves the end product, which means that originality, authorship, and human expression carry a different kind of weight."

**Q: To what extent should disclosures to consumers be made about the use of genAI in creative software such as video games?** 

> "This one is still evolving in my mind. Using AI to debug a video game is quite different from using it to generate the game’s characters, dialogue, or music. The first leaves the creative substance in human hands while the second reaches into the stuff players are paying to experience. But if we required disclosure of every incidental use, the label would end up on everything and become meaningless."

While I think my ideals are somewhat in line with Dr. Tiwana's, I think there is still a considerable amount of nuance to the debate. I do personally believe that due to the nature of programming, AI disclosures are somewhat unrealistic to require, because of how code is often shared and copied it would be nigh impossible to determine if an LLM was the original source of any specific code snippet. I'm not sure where the gaming industry will be in terms of ideals five more years from now, but I do not think that witch-hunting developers who clearly put their heart and soul into a game should be lambasted for utilizing AI-assisted code.

Ultimately, as most things in this world do, it comes down to personal opinion. As far as *Big Walk* is concerned, AI was used exclusively to overcome difficult programming challenges, not creating the visuals, story, and experience. I therefore have no issue with it. But I understand that my opinion does not reflect everyone's. If you find this act morally reprehensible, then you can and should be vocal about it. With how much AI has been impacting literally everything we interact with, our own voices are the most important thing we still hold onto.

To this end, we have instituted an AI policy (found on our [about](https://hydroxide.me/about/) page) regarding reviewing games with certain AI-generated elements. This is currently limited to assets that would fall under the art/music categories with elements such as AI-generated or AI-assisted code being up to the discretion of individual authors. Our *Big Walk* review will remain up, in its current state. 

Editorial #002